Immigration reform as a potential solution to the aging population
Kyle Huffman • April 27, 2023
Immigration reform is one of the most powerful tools and opportunities the United States has to address several of our nation’s most pressing economic issues, and it should be utilized as one of the primary tools to address the coming concern of the United States’ aging population and the possibility of substantial population decline.
Numerous economic studies have shown the relationship between economic development and population decline. In the vast majority of cases, economic development, resulting in better wages and better working and living conditions for the population, results in a decline in birthrate as the opportunity cost of having children increases for parents. This can be seen in many countries around the world facing this issue today including Japan, China, South Korea, Germany, and Spain, among many others. The United States is no different, the baby boomer generation is aging and increasingly withdrawing from the workforce and transitioning into retirement. As populations age in developed countries, declining birth rates have become a growing concern. Countries with low birth rates face a shrinking workforce, decreased economic growth, and higher demand for social services, such as healthcare and pensions. A falling birthrate often means a decrease in the number of young people entering the workforce, which can lead to a shortage of workers, decreased economic growth, and an increased burden on the healthcare and social security systems as the number of workers paying into these systems shrink, while the number of people relying on these systems grows.
You have likely heard the phrase “nobody wants to work anymore” expressed numerous times in the media in various forms. The truth is this sentiment will only continue to be exacerbated as the largest generational subset of the American population exits the workforce increasingly in the coming years.
However, the United States has a unique opportunity to address these issues and minimize the economic consequences of an aging and shrinking population – through its immigration system. Enhancing liberal immigration policies and increasing pathways to legal immigration status in the United States is one of the most powerful mechanisms the United States can employ to address these looming issues. According to a 2020 survey conducted by the United Nations, the United States is the most popular destination for immigrants in the world. As a destination that is currently sought by many hopeful immigrants from countries all over the world, the United State should take advantage of this opportunity and high demand for immigration to offset the declining birthrate and the eventual losses to the labor force as a result.
By attracting immigrants, the United States can increase the number of people in the workforce, which can help to offset the effects of a declining birthrate. Immigrants bring with them skills, experience, and a willingness to work, all of which can help to boost a country's economy. Additionally, many immigrants are young, which can help to offset the aging population in many first world nations, the United States included.
Liberal immigration policies can also help to address another important issue: diversity. By welcoming immigrants from different backgrounds, countries can benefit from the perspectives and experiences of people from different cultures. This can help to foster innovation and creativity, which can in turn lead to economic growth.
Of course, there are also challenges associated with liberal immigration policies. Some people are concerned that immigrants may take jobs away from native-born workers or strain social services. However, these concerns can be addressed through careful policy design and implementation. For example, policies could be put in place to ensure that immigrants have the necessary skills and qualifications to fill labor shortages, and that they are integrated into the community in a way that supports their success. Moreover, statistics show that immigrants are more likely to go into business for themselves compared to the native-born population. This means that immigrants are more likely to create new businesses, i.e., new job opportunities, compared to native-born counterparts, which helps to address the concern that immigrants will reduce the job opportunities available for U.S. workers.
For these reasons, among many others, the United States would benefit from substantial immigration reform and increasing pathways to legal immigration for skilled workers in this country. The profound benefits that are possible through responsible and strategic immigration policy could be a significant part of the solution to some of the biggest economic challenges that the United States will face in the coming decades, and this is important to consider the next time you see the same news station simultaneously proclaim, “Nobody wants to work anymore!” and “We need to close our borders!” at the same time.
This blog is not intended to be legal advice and nothing here should be construed as establishing an attorney client relationship. Please schedule a consultation with an immigration attorney before acting on any information read here.
During the recent administration there has been an increase in issuance of Requests for Evidence for EB-1A petitions for those of Extraordinary Ability. A Request for Evidence is a request that is made by USCIS that should explain how the evidence is deficient in proving the criteria argued and what additional evidence needs to be provided by the applicant to meet the criteria. EB-1A petitions are already normally subject to higher scrutiny because their approval is the first step needed to apply for Lawful Permanent Residence or a green card. USCIS normally requires not just evidence but that the evidence be provided with context and information to show why it matters in a particular field. For example, if you were providing evidence of your membership in an organization that requires outstanding achievements of its members, just providing evidence of the membership is not enough. You must explain what that membership is and provide background information on the organization granting the membership. You also need to provide evidence on the criteria that is used to select the members, information on those who select the members to show that they are recognized experts, other documentation such as articles about the membership organization to show its importance, and any other relevant evidence and background information to show that the criteria is met. A request for evidence being issued prior to the current administration was not uncommon, but in the current climate it is more surprising to not receive a request for evidence for this type of case. It is important to remember that a request for evidence is not a denial. Depending on the validity of the information in the request and the substance some Requests for Evidence can be overcome, and the case be approved. It is important to carefully review the request and note if there are any errors in the content and application of the regulations by USCIS. If you have an attorney, you should work with them and make sure that you provide any evidence you think may be helpful. Although there is a deadline by which a response must be submitted, attention to detail and patience will go a long way when dealing with having to respond to a request for evidence. If you believe you may qualify for this type of visa, please feel free to contact our office.
Once you have connected with a college program, have been admitted to the school, and deemed eligible to compete athletically, you will need to secure an F-1 student visa in order to actually attend your new college and begin your time as a student athlete. The first step in the visa process is to receive your Form I-2
For many talented athletes around the world, U.S. college athletics represent a remarkable opportunity to combine elite athletic competition with higher education. In sports such as basketball, soccer, track and field, and tennis, among others, hundreds of colleges and universities across the United States offer struct
